PROPOSAL FOR A NEW WORK ITEM
|
Date of presentation of proposal:
|
Proposer:
Japan
|
|
Secretariat:
|
ISO/IEC JTC 1 N XXXX
|
A proposal for a new work item shall be
submitted to the secretariat of the ISO/IEC joint technical committee
concerned with a copy to the ISO Central Secretariat.
Presentation of the proposal -
to be completed by the proposer Guidelines for proposing and
justifying a new work item are given in ISO Guide 26.
|
Title
TM4PL Benchmark (Topic Maps for Practice
Learning) Benchmark
|
|
Scope: This proposed technical report
specifies the TM4PL benchmark to assess qualitatively and
quantitatively TMengine according to TMDM, TMQL, and TMCL
|
|
Purpose and justification
The purposes
of the TM4PL (Topic Maps for Practice Learning) Benchmark
are:
To provide a
uniform TM framework for data and workload specification to
assess topic maps engines according to some quality and quantity
performance metrics.
To encourage the
usage of benchmark to evaluate topic maps-based engines, and
To improve the quality assessment of topic
maps technology and standardization.
Quality and Quantity assessments are two key
issues to improve the usage of topic maps in industrial and
end-user communities. It will be also a way to motivate people to
improve toward that goal.
|
|
Programme of work
If the proposed new work item is approved , which
of the following document(s) is (are) expected to be developed?
____ a single International Standard more than one
International Standard (expected number: ........ )
____ a
multi-part International Standard consisting of .......... parts
___ an amendment or amendments to the following International
Standard(s) ...
_X___ a technical report , type ...........
|
|
Relevant documents to be considered
|
|
Cooperation and liaison
None
|
|
Preparatory work offered with target
date(s)
Draft requirements
|
|
Signature:
|
|
Will the service of a maintenance agency or
registration authority be required? No
- If yes, have you
identified a potential candidate? ................
- If yes,
indicate name
.............................................................
Are there any known requirements for coding?
No
-If yes, please specify on a separate page
Are there any known requirements for cultural and
linguistic adaptability? No
- If yes, please specify on a
separate page
Does the proposed standard concern known patented
items? No
- If yes, please provide full information in an annex
|
Comments and recommendations of the JTC 1
Secretariat - attach a separate page as an
annex, if necessary
|
Comments with respect to the proposal in
general, and recommendations thereon:
It
is proposed to assign this new item to JTC 1/SC 34
|
Voting on the proposal -
Each P-member of the ISO/IEC joint technical committee has an
obligation to vote within the time limits laid down (normally three
months after the date of circulation).
|
Date of circulation:
|
Closing date for voting:
|
Signature of Secretary:
|
|
NEW WORK ITEM PROPOSAL - PROJECT ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA
|
|
|
|
Criterion
|
Validity
|
Explanation
|
|
A Business Requirement
|
|
|
|
A.1 Market Requirement
|
Essential __
Desirable __X_
Supportive ___
|
New users of ISO/IEC 13250 require benchmark
framework
|
|
A.2 Regulatory Context
|
Essential ___
Desirable ___
Supportive ___
Not
Relevant _X_
|
|
|
B. Related Work
|
|
|
|
B.1 Completion/Maintence of current standards
|
Yes __
No_X__
|
|
|
B.2 Commitment to other organization
|
Yes ___
No_X_
|
|
|
B.3 Other Source of standards
|
Yes ___
No__
|
|
|
C. Technical Status
|
|
|
|
C.1 Mature Technology
|
Yes __
No___
|
|
|
C.2 Prospective Technology
|
Yes ___
No__
|
|
|
C.3 Models/Tools
|
Yes _X__
No__
|
|
|
D. Conformity Assessment and Interoperability
|
|
|
|
D.1 Conformity Assessment
|
Yes ___
No__
|
|
|
D.2 Interoperability
|
Yes ___
No__
|
|
|
E. Cultural and Linguistic Adaptability
|
Yes __
No___
|
|
|
F. Other Justification
|
|
|
Notes to Proforma
A. Business Relevance. That which identifies market place
relevance in terms of what problem is being solved and or need being
addressed.
A.1. Market Requirement. When submitting a NP, the proposer shall
identify the nature of the Market Requirement, assessing the extent
to which it is essential, desirable or merely supportive of some
other project.
A.2 Technical Regulation. If a Regulatory requirement is deemed to
exist - e.g. for an area of public concern e.g. Information Security,
Data protection, potentially leading to regulatory/public interest
action based on the use of this voluntary international standard -
the proposer shall identify this here.
B. Related Work. Aspects of the relationship of this NP to
other areas of standardization work shall be identified in this
section.
B.1 Competition/Maintenance. If this NP is concerned with
completing or maintaining existing standards, those concerned shall
be identified here.
B.2 External Commitment. Groups, bodies, or fora external to JTC1
to which a commitment has been made by JTC for cooperation and or
collaboration on this NP shall be identified here.
B.3 External Std/Specification. If other activities creating
standards or specifications in this topic area are known to exist or
be planned, and which might be available to JTC1 as PAS, they shall
be identified here.
C. Technical Status. The proposer shall indicate here an
assessment of the extent to which the proposed standard is supported
by current technology.
C.1 Mature Technology. Indicate here the extent to which the
technology is reasonably stable and ripe for standardization.
C.2 Prospective Technology. If the NP is anticipatory in nature
based on expected or forecasted need, this shall be indicated here.
C.3 Models/Tools. If the NP relates to the creation of supportive
reference models or tools, this shall be indicated here.
D. Conformity Assessment and Interoperability
D.1 Indicate here if Conformity Assessment is relevant to your
project. If so, indicate how it is addressed in your project plan.
D.2 Indicate here if Interoperability is relevant to your project.
If so, indicate how it is addressed in your project plan.
E. Cultural and Linguistic Adaptability Indicate
here if cultural and linguistic adaptability is applicable to your
project. If so, indicate how it is addressed in your project plan.
F. Other Justification Any
other aspects of background information justifying this NP shall be
indicated here.
