Title: |
Summary of Voting on JTC 1/SC 34 N 326 – FPDAM 1 to ISO/IEC 10179: Extensions to DSSSL |
Source: |
|
Project: |
ISO/IEC 10179 – Extensions to DSSSL |
Project editors: |
S. Kaida |
Status: |
|
Action: |
Project Editors are requested to review comments and take them into consideration when preparing revised text. |
Date: |
25 November 2002 |
Summary: |
Based on the result of voting, this document has been APPROVED. |
Distribution: |
SC34 and Liaisons |
Refer to: |
|
Supercedes: |
|
Reply to: |
Dr. James David Mason
|
SC 34 Voting Summary on JTC 1/SC 34 N 326
FPDAM 1 to ISO/IEC 10179: Extensions to DSSSL
P-Member
|
APPROVAL
OF THE DRAFT AS PRESENTED
|
APPROVAL
OF THE DRAFT WITH COMMENTS AS GIVEN ON THE ATTACHED
|
DISAPPROVAL
OF THE DRAFT FOR REASONS ON THE ATTACHED
|
Acceptance
of these reasons and appropriate changes in the text will change our vote
to approval
|
ABSTENTION
(For Reasons Below):
|
Brazil |
|
|
|
|
|
Canada |
X |
|
|
|
|
China |
|
|
|
|
|
Denmark |
X |
|
|
|
|
France |
|
|
|
|
|
Ireland |
|
|
|
|
|
Italy |
|
|
|
|
|
Japan |
X |
|
|
|
|
Republic of Korea |
|
|
|
|
|
Netherlands
|
X |
|
|
|
|
Norway
|
X |
|
|
|
|
United Kingdom
|
|
|
X |
X |
|
United States
|
X |
|
|
|
|
TOTAL |
6 |
0 |
1 |
1 |
0 |
United Kingdom
UK Vote: : DISAPPROVAL OF THE DRAFT
FOR REASONS APPENDED BELOW. Acceptance of
these reasons and appropriate
changes in the text will change our vote to approval
Technical
Comments
Clause
12.6.29.1
Explain more clearly what does it
mean to say that a sound-voice flow object should be "output
rather
than displayed or inlined". What
constitutes the display of a sound-voice flow object? How does this
differ
from output?
Clause B.1
In definition of quantity and
related numbers the last sentence is unclear. What constitutes a "large
size
of numerical object" when it is
displayed? Is this decision system dependent?
Clause B.3
In the definition of subgrove-spec
make it clearer what "class add null remove children"
means/represents.
Annex D
It should be made clear that this
annex is derived from the SGML Extended Facilities defined in Annex
A
of the second edition of ISO 10744.
At all times the normative definitions in 10744 have
precedence
over those in this informative
annex
Editorial
Comments
Introduction
Change "This amendment 1" to "This
amendment"
In a) change "on flow object classes
of" to "flow object classes for"
Clause
12.6.28.5
Change "specify" for
"specifies".
Change "initial value" to "default
value" (twice)
Clause
12.6.28.6
Explain meaning of terms
voice-source and semantics as they are not formally defined DSSSL
terms.
Clause
12.6.28.7
Change "classes be" to "classes may
be"
Explain meaning of OK-ng and
information.
Clause
12.6.29
Change "a external entity" to "an
external entity"
Change "object of" to "objects
of".
Change "on" to "as
an"
Clause
12.6.29.2
Change "be atomic" to "be an
atomic"
Change "output?: is boolean" to
"output?: boolean" to conform with other paragraphs.
Change "outputed" to
"output"
Change "specifications is" to
"specifications are". (It is unclear why this paragraph should be specific
to
animation flow objects and not to
sound-voice objects as well.)
Clause
12.3.6
First list in this section
conflicts, without adequate explanation, with the list at the start of
12.3.5.
The text at the start of the list
could be changed to:
"This amendment, therefore, extends
the set of DSSSL formatting areas to the following set:"
Clause
12.2.1
Change "This API shall report" to
"This API reports"
(It is unclear why the changes to
12.2 have been listed after those to 12.6.)
Annex B
In first sentence, change "on" to
"for"
Clause B.1
In first sentence correct spelling
of "following"
In definition of symbol change
"script" to "scripts"
In definition of char change
"charcter" to "character" and remove "circle" from "open circle
parentheses"
In definition of languate correct
spelling of "spellcheck"
In definition of node-list, change
"of grove" to "of a grove", "by node-list as" to "by a node-list with"
and
"transformation" to
"transformations"
Clause B.4
In definition of length should
"rapage-height" just be "page-height"?
Annex D
Change "amang" to "among" and insert
"a " after "called"