P3070R1
Formatting enums

"It is a mistake to think you can solve any major problems just with potatoes." ― Douglas Adams

1. Introduction

std::format, as introduced in C++20, has significantly improved string formatting in C++. However, custom formatting for enumeration types currently requires creating somewhat verbose formatter specializations. This proposal aims to introduce a more intuitive and simpler method to define custom formats for enums using format_as. When formatting enums as integers it is also more efficient than a formatter specialization.

2. Changes since R0

• Added the SG16 poll results.

3. SG16 Poll

Poll 3: Forward P3070R0 to LEWG.

No objection to unanimous consent.

4. Motivation and Scope

Enums are fundamental in C++ for representing sets of named constants. There is often a need to convert these enums to string representations, especially for logging, debugging, or interfacing with users. The current methods for customizing enum formatting in std::format are not as user-friendly or integrated as they could be.

With the introduction of a format_as extension for enums, we aim to:

• Simplify the process of defining custom formatting representations for enums.

• Improve enum formatting efficiency.

• Ensure compatibility with existing code and minimal disruption.

Consider the following example:

namespace kevin_namespacy {
enum class film {
  house_of_cards, american_beauty, se7en = 7
};
}

If we want to format this enum as an underlying type with std::format we have two options. The first option is defining a formatter specialization:

template <>
struct std::formatter<kevin_namespacy::film> : formatter<int> {
  auto format(kevin_namespacy::film f, format_context& ctx) {
    return formatter<int>::format(std::to_underlying(f), ctx);
  }
};

The drawback of this option is that even with forwarding to another formatter there is a fair amount of boilerplate and it cannot be done in the same namespace.

The second option is converting the enum to the underlying type:

film f = kevin_namespacy::se7en;
auto s = std::format("{}", std::to_underlying(f));

The drawback of the second option is that the conversion has to be done at every call site.

5. Proposed Change

We propose adding a format_as extension point to std::format. format_as is a function discovered by the argument-dependent lookup (ADL) that takes an enum to be formatted as the argument and converts it to an object of another formattable type, normally an integer or a string.

This significantly improves user experience by eliminating almost all boilerplate:

Before:

namespace kevin_namespacy {
enum class film {...};
}
template <>
struct std::formatter<kevin_namespacy::film> : formatter<int> {
  auto format(kevin_namespacy::film f, format_context& ctx) const {
    return formatter<int>::format(std::to_underlying(f), ctx);
  }
};

After:

namespace kevin_namespacy {
enum class film {...};
auto format_as(film f) { return std::to_underlying(f); }
}

The semantics of format_as is the same as the corresponding "forwarding" formatter specialization.

format_as can be used to format enums as strings as well:

enum class color {red, green, blue};

auto format_as(color c) -> std::string_view {
  switch (c) {
    case color::red:   return "red";
    case color::green: return "green";
    case color::blue:  return "blue";
  }
}

auto s = std::format("{}", color::red); // s == "red"

Apart from usability improvement, if the target type is one of the built-in types directly supported by std::format, formatting can be implemented more efficiently. Instead of going through the general-purpose formatter API the enum can be converted directly to the built-in type at the call site. And conversion from an enum to its underlying type is effectively a noop so there is no effect on the binary size.

The difference can be seen on the following benchmark results for an enum similar to std::byte:

---------------------------------------------------------------------
Benchmark                           Time             CPU   Iterations
---------------------------------------------------------------------
BM_Formatter                     17.7 ns         17.7 ns     38037070
BM_FormatAs                      8.90 ns         8.88 ns     79036210

Considering that format_as has almost 2x better performance, this paper also proposes making std::byte formattable using the new facility.

6. Impact on the Standard

This proposal is an additive change to the existing <format> standard library component and does not necessitate alterations to current language features or core library interfaces. It is a backward-compatible enhancement that addresses a common use case in std::format.

7. Implementation

The proposed extension API has been implemented in the open-source {fmt} library ([FMT]) and as of December 2023 has been shipping for two major versions. It has been recently extended to all user-defined types and not just enums but this is not proposed in the current paper since usage experience is still limited.

Appendix A: Benchmark

This appendix gives the source code of the benchmark used for comparing performance of format_as with a formatter specialization.

#include <benchmark/benchmark.h>
#include <fmt/core.h>

enum class byte_for_formatter : unsigned char {};

template <>
struct fmt::formatter<byte_for_formatter> : fmt::formatter<unsigned char> {
  auto format(byte_for_formatter b, fmt::format_context& ctx) {
    return fmt::formatter<unsigned char>::format(
      static_cast<unsigned char>(b), ctx);
  }
};

enum class byte_for_format_as : unsigned char {};

auto format_as(byte_for_format_as b) { return static_cast<unsigned char>(b); }

static void BM_Formatter(benchmark::State& state) {
  auto b = byte_for_formatter();
  for (auto _ : state) {
    std::string formatted = fmt::format("{}", b);
    benchmark::DoNotOptimize(formatted);
  }
}
BENCHMARK(BM_Formatter);

static void BM_FormatAs(benchmark::State& state) {
  auto b = byte_for_format_as();
  for (auto _ : state) {
    std::string formatted = fmt::format("{}", b);
    benchmark::DoNotOptimize(formatted);
  }
}
BENCHMARK(BM_FormatAs);

BENCHMARK_MAIN();