Submdspan

Document #: P2630
Date: 2022-08-15
Project: Programming Language C++
LEWG
Reply-to: Christian Trott
<>
Damien Lebrun-Grandie
<>
Mark Hoemmen
<>

1 Revision History

1.1 Initial Version 2022-08 Mailing

2 Description

Until one of the last revisions, the mdspan paper P0009 contained submdspan, the subspan or “slicing” function that returns a view of a subset of an existing mdspan. This function was considered critical for the overall functionality of mdspan. However, due to review time constraints it was removed from P0009 in order for mdspan to be included in C++23.

This paper restores submdspan. It also expands on the original proposal by

Creating subspans is an integral capability of many, if not all programming languages with multidimensional arrays. These include Fortran, Matlab, Python, and Python’s NumPy extension.

Subspans are important because they enable code reuse. For example, the inner loop in a dense matrix-vector product actually represents a dot product – an inner product of two vectors. If one already has a function for such an inner product, then a natural implementation would simply reuse that function. The LAPACK linear algebra library depends on subspan reuse for the performance of its one-sided “blocked” matrix factorizations (Cholesky, LU, and QR). These factorizations reuse textbook non-blocked algorithms by calling them on groups of contiguous columns at a time. This lets LAPACK spend as much time in dense matrix-matrix multiply (or algorithms with analogous performance) as possible.

The following example demonstrates this code reuse feature of subspans. Given a rank-3 mdspan representing a three-dimensional grid of regularly spaced points in a rectangular prism, the function zero_surface sets all elements on the surface of the 3-dimensional shape to zero. It does so by reusing a function zero_2d that takes a rank-2 mdspan.

// Set all elements of a rank-2 mdspan to zero.
template<class T, class E, class L, class A>
void zero_2d(mdspan<T,E,L,A> grid2d) {
  static_assert(grid2d.rank() == 2);
  for(int i = 0; i < grid2d.extent(0); ++i) {
    for(int j = 0; j < grid2d.extent(1); ++j) {
      grid2d[i,j] = 0;
    }
  }
}

template<class T, class E, class L, class A>
void zero_surface(mdspan<T,E,L,A> grid3d) {
  static_assert(grid3d.rank() == 3);
  zero_2d(submdspan(grid3d, 0, full_extent, full_extent));
  zero_2d(submdspan(grid3d, full_extent, 0, full_extent));
  zero_2d(submdspan(grid3d, full_extent, full_extent, 0));
  zero_2d(submdspan(grid3d, grid3d.extent(0)-1, full_extent, full_extent));
  zero_2d(submdspan(grid3d, full_extent, grid3d.extent(1)-1, full_extent));
  zero_2d(submdspan(grid3d, full_extent, full_extent, grid3d.extent(2)-1));
}

2.1 Design of submdspan

As previously proposed in an earlier revision of P0009, submdspan is a free function. Its first parameter is an mdspan x, and the remaining x.rank() parameters are slice specifiers, one for each dimension of x. The slice specifiers describe which elements of the range [0,x.extent(d)) are part of the multidimensional index space of the returned mdspan.

This leads to the following fundamental signature:

template<class T, class E, class L, class A,
         class ... SliceArgs)
auto submdspan(mdspan<T,E,L,A> x, SliceArgs ... args);

where E.rank() must be equal to sizeof...(SliceArgs).

2.1.1 Slice Specifiers

2.1.1.1 P0009’s slice specifiers

In P0009 we originally proposed three kinds of slice specifiers.

2.1.1.2 Strided index range slice specifier

We propose here an additional kind of slice specifier, the type strided_index_range for taking a strided range in an extent. This type takes three values:

This type uses the length instead of the end index, so that the returned subspan can have a compile-time extent value, even if it starts at a run-time offset value. We use a struct with named fields instead of a tuple, in order to avoid confusion with the order of the three values.

2.1.1.2.1 Template argument deduction

We really want template argument deduction to work for strided_index_range. Languages like Fortran, Matlab, and Python have a concise notation for creating the equivalent kind of slice inline. It would be unfortunate if users had to write

auto y = submdspan(x, strided_index_range<int, int, int>{0, 10, 3});

instead of

auto y = submdspan(x, strided_index_range{0, 10, 3});

Not having template argument deduction would make it particularly unpleasant to mix compile-time and run-time values. For example, to express the offset and extent as compile-time values and the stride as a run-time value without template argument deduction, users would need to write

auto y = submdspan(x, strided_index_range<integral_constant<size_t, 0>, integral_constant<size_t, 10>, 3>{{}, {}, 3});

Template argument deduction would permit a consistently value-oriented style.

auto y = submdspan(x, strided_index_range{integral_constant<size_t, 0>{}, integral_constant<size_t, 10>{}, 3});

This case of compile-time offset and extent and run-time stride would permit optimizations like

2.1.1.2.2 Designated initializers

We would also like to permit use of designated initializers with strided_index_range. This would let users choose a more verbose, self-documenting style. It would also avoid any confusion about the order of arguments.

auto y = submdspan(x, strided_index_range{.offset=0, .extent=10, .stride=3});

Designated initializers only work for aggregate types. This has implications for template argument deduction. Template argument deduction for aggregates is a C++20 feature. However, few compilers support it currently. GCC added full support in version 11, MSVC in 19.27, and EDG eccp in 6.3, according to the cppreference.com compiler support table. For example, Clang 14.0.0 supports designated initializers, and non-aggregate (class) template argument deduction, but it does not currently compile either of the following.

auto a = strided_index_range{.offset=0, .extent=10, .stride=3};
auto b = strided_index_range<int, int, int>{.offset=0, .extent=10, .stride=3});

Implementers may want to make mdspan available for users of earlier C++ versions. The result need not comply fully with the specification, but should be as usable and forward-compatible as possible. Implementers can back-port strided_index_range by adding the following two constructors.

strided_index_range() = default;
strided_index_range(OffsetType offset_, ExtentType extent_, StrideType stride_)
  : offset(offset_), extent_(extent), stride(stride_)
{}

These constructors make strided_index_range no longer an aggregate, but restore (class) template argument deduction. They also preserve the struct’s properties of being a structural type (usable as a non-type template parameter) and trivially copyable (for compatibility with other programming languages).

2.1.1.3 Compile-time integral values in slices

We also propose that any integral value (on its own, in a tuple, or in strided_index_range) can be specified as an integral_constant. This ensures that the value can be baked into the return type of submdspan. For example, layout mappings could be entirely compile time.

Here are some simple examples for rank-1 mdspan.

int* ptr = ...;
int N = ...;
mdspan a(ptr, N);

// subspan of a single element
auto a_sub1 = submdspan(a, 1);
static_assert(decltype(a_sub1)::rank() == 0);
assert(&a_sub1() == &a(1));

// subrange
auto a_sub2 = submdspan(a, tuple{1, 4});
static_assert(decltype(a_sub2)::rank() == 1);
assert(&a_sub2(0) == &a(1));
assert(a_sub2.extent(0) == 3);

// subrange with stride
auto a_sub3 = submdspan(a, strided_index_range{1, 7, 2});
static_assert(decltype(a_sub3)::rank() == 1);
assert(&a_sub3(0) == &a(1));
assert(&a_sub3(3) == &a(7));
assert(a_sub3.extent(0) == 4);

// full range
auto a_sub4 = submdspan(a, full_extent);
static_assert(decltype(a_sub4)::rank() == 1);
assert(a_sub4(0) == a(0));
assert(a_sub4.extent(0) == a.extent(0));

In multidimensional use cases these specifiers can be mixed and matched.

int* ptr = ...;
int N0 = ..., N1 = ..., N2 = ..., N3 = ..., N4 = ...;
mdspan a(ptr, N0, N1, N2, N3, N4);

auto a_sub = submdspan(a,full_extent_t(), 3, strided_index_range{2,N2-5, 2}, 4, tuple{3, N5-5});

// two integral specifiers so the rank is reduced by 2
static_assert(decltype(a_sub) == 3);
// 1st dimension is taking the whole extent
assert(a_sub.extent(0) == a.extent(0));
// the new 2nd dimension corresponds to the old 3rd dimension
assert(a_sub.extent(1) == (a.extent(2) - 5)/2);
assert(a_sub.stride(1) == a.stride(2)*2);
// the new 3rd dimension corresponds to the old 5th dimension
assert(a_sub.extent(2) == a.extent(4)-8);

assert(&a_sub(1,5,7) == &a(1, 3, 2+5*2, 4, 3+7));

2.1.2 Customization Points

In order to create the new mdspan from an existing mdspan src, we need three things:

Computing the new data handle is done via an offset and the original accessor’s offset function, while the new accessor is constructed from the old accessor.

That leaves the construction of the new mapping and the calculation of the offset handed to the offset function. Both of those operations depend only on the old mapping and the slice specifiers.

In order to support calling submdspan on mdspan with custom layout policies, we need to introduce two customization points for computing the mapping and the offset. Both take as input the original mapping, and the slice specifiers.

template<class Mapping, class ... SliceArgs>
auto submdspan_mapping(const Mapping&, SliceArgs...) { /* ... */ }

template<class Mapping, class ... SliceArgs>
size_t submdspan_offset(const Mapping&, SliceArgs...) { /* ... */ }

With these components we can sketch out the implementation of submdspan.

template<class T, class E, class L, class A,
         class ... SliceArgs)
auto submdspan(const mdspan<T,E,L,A>& src, SliceArgs ... args) {
  size_t sub_offset = submdspan_offset(src.mapping(), args...);
  auto sub_map = submdspan_mapping(src.mapping(), args...);
  typename A::offset_policy sub_acc(src.accessor());
  typename A::offset_policy::data_handle_type 
    sub_handle = src.accessor().offset(src.data_handle(), sub_offset);
  return mdspan(sub_handle, sub_map, sub_acc);
}

To support custom layouts, std::submdspan calls submdspan_offset and submdspan_mapping using argument-dependent lookup.

However, not all layout mappings may support efficient slicing for all possible slice specifier combinations. Thus, we do not propose to add these customization points to the layout policy requirements.

2.1.3 Making sure submdspan behavior meets expectations

The slice specifiers of submdspan completely determine two properties of its result:

  1. the extents of the result, and
  2. what elements of the input of submdspan are also represented in the result.

Both of these things are independent of the layout mapping policy.

The approach we described above orthogonalizes handling of accessors and mappings. Thus, we can define both of the above properties via the multidimensional index spaces, regardless of what it means to “refer to the same element.” (For example, accessors may use proxy references and data handle types other than C++ pointers. This makes it hard to define what “same element” means.) That will let us define pre-conditions for submdspan which specify the required behavior of any user-provided submdspan_mapping and submdspan_offset function.

One function which can help with that, and additionally is needed to implement submdspan_mapping and submdspan_offset for the layouts the standard provides, is a function to compute the submdspan’s extents. We will propose this function as a public function in the standard:

template<class IndexType, class ... Extents, class ... SliceArgs>
auto submdspan_extents(const extents<IndexType, Extents...>, SliceArgs ...);

The resulting extents object must have certain properties for logical correctness.

For performance and preservation of compile-time knowledge, we also require the following.

3 Wording

3.1 Add subsection 22.7.X [mdspan.submdspan] with the following

24.7.� submdspan [mdspan.submdspan]

24.7.�.1 overview [mdspan.submdspan.overview]

1 The submdspan facilities create a new mdspan from an existing input mdspan. The new mdspan’s elements refer to a subset of the elements of the input mdspan.

namespace std {
  template<class OffsetType, class LengthType, class StrideType>
    class strided_index_range;

  template<class IndexType, class... Extents, class... SliceSpecifiers>
    constexpr auto submdspan_extents(const extents<IndexType, Extents...>&,
                                     SliceSpecifiers ...);

  template<class E, class... SliceSpecifiers>
    constexpr auto submdspan_mapping(
      const layout_left::mapping<E>& src, 
      SliceSpecifiers ... slices) -> see below;

  template<class E, class... SliceSpecifiers>
    constexpr auto submdspan_mapping(
      const layout_right::mapping<E>& src, 
      SliceSpecifiers ... slices) -> see below;

  template<class E, class... SliceSpecifiers>
    constexpr auto submdspan_mapping(
      const layout_stride::mapping<E>& src, 
      SliceSpecifiers ... slices) -> see below;

  template<class E, class... SliceSpecifiers>
    constexpr size_t submdspan_offset(
      const layout_left::mapping<E>& src, 
      SliceSpecifiers ... slices);

  template<class E, class... SliceSpecifiers>
    constexpr size_t submdspan_offset(
      const layout_right::mapping<E>& src, 
      SliceSpecifiers ... slices);

  template<class E, class... SliceSpecifiers>
    constexpr size_t submdspan_offset(
      const layout_stride::mapping<E>& src, 
      SliceSpecifiers ... slices);

  // [mdspan.submdspan], submdspan creation
  template<class ElementType, class Extents, class LayoutPolicy,
           class AccessorPolicy, class... SliceSpecifiers>
    constexpr auto submdspan(
      const mdspan<ElementType, Extents, LayoutPolicy, AccessorPolicy>& src,
      SliceSpecifiers...slices) -> see below;
}

2 The SliceSpecifier template argument(s) and the corresponding value(s) of the arguments of submdspan after src determine the subset of src that the mdspan returned by submdspan views.

3 Each submdspan overload specified in this subclause calls submdspan_mapping and submdspan_offset unqualified, so as to enable argument dependent lookup ([basic.lookup.argdep]).

4 For each function defined in subsection [mdspan.submdspan] that takes a parameter pack named slices as an argument:

24.7.�.2 strided_index_range [mdspan.submdspan.strided_index_range]

template<class OffsetType, class ExtentType, class StrideType>
struct strided_index_range {
  using offset_type = OffsetType;
  using extent_type = ExtentType;
  using stride_type = StrideType;

  OffsetType offset;
  ExtentType extent;
  StrideType stride;
};

1 strided_index_range represents a set of extent regularly spaced integer indices. The indices start at offset, and increase by increments of stride.

2 strided_index_range is an aggregate type.

3 Mandates:

[Note: strided_index_range{.offset=1, .extent=10, .stride=3} indicates the indices 1, 4, 7, and 10. Indices are selected from the half-open interval [1, 1 + 10). - end note]

24.7.�.3 Exposition-only helpers [mdspan.submdspan.helpers]

template<class T>
struct is-strided-index-range: false_type {};

template<class OffsetType, class ExtentType, class StrideType>
struct is-strided-index-range<strided_index_range<OffsetType, ExtentType, StrideType>>: true_type {};
template<class IndexType, class ... SliceSpecifiers>
typename IndexType first_(size_t k, SliceSpecifiers... slices);

1 Mandates: IndexType is a signed or unsigned integer type.

2 Let φk denote the following value:

3 Preconditions: φk is representable as a value of type IndexType.

4 Returns: extents<IndexType>::index-cast( φk ).

template<class Extents, class ... SliceSpecifiers>
size_t last_(size_t k, const Extents& ext, SliceSpecifiers... slices);

5 Mandates: Extents is a specialization of extents.

6 Let index_type name the type typename Extents::index_type.

7 Let λk denote the following value:

8 Preconditions: λk is representable as a value of type index_type.

9 Returns: Extents::index-cast( λk ).

template<class IndexType, size_t N, class ... SliceSpecifiers>
array<IndexType, sizeof...(SliceSpecifiers)> src-indices(const array<IndexType, N>& indices, SliceSpecifiers ... slices);

10 Mandates: IndexType is a signed or unsigned integer type.

11 Returns: an array<IndexType, sizeof...(SliceSpecifiers)> src_idx such that src_idx[k] equals

24.7.�.4 submdspan_extents function [mdspan.submdspan.extents]

template<class IndexType, class ... Extents, class ... SliceSpecifiers>
auto submdspan_extents(const extents<IndexType, Extents...>& src_exts, SliceSpecifiers ... slices);

1 Constraints:

2 Mandates: For each rank index k of src.extents(), exactly one of the following is true:

3 Preconditions: For each rank index r of src.extents(), all of the following are true:

4 Let SubExtents be a specialization of extents such that:

5 Returns: a value of type SubExtents ext such that for each k for which map-rank[k] != dynamic_extent is true:

24.7.�.5 Layout specializations of submdspan_mapping [mdspan.submdspan.mapping]

  template<class Extents, class... SliceSpecifiers>
    constexpr auto submdspan_mapping(
      const layout_left::mapping<Extents>& src, 
      SliceSpecifiers ... slices) -> see below;

  template<class Extents, class... SliceSpecifiers>
    constexpr auto submdspan_mapping(
      const layout_right::mapping<Extents>& src, 
      SliceSpecifiers ... slices) -> see below;

  template<class Extents, class... SliceSpecifiers>
    constexpr auto submdspan_mapping(
      const layout_stride::mapping<Extents>& src, 
      SliceSpecifiers ... slices) -> see below;

1 Let index_type name the type typename Extents::index_type.

2 Constraints:

3 Mandates: For each rank index k of src.extents(), exactly one of the following is true:

4 Preconditions: For each rank index r of src.extents(), all of the following are true:

5 Let sub_ext be the result of submdspan_extents(src.extents(), slices...) and let SubExtents be decltype(sub_ext).

6 Let sub_strides be an array<SubExtents::index_type, SubExtents::rank() such that sub_strides[map-rank[k]] == src.stride(k) is true for each rank index k of src.extents() for which map-rank[k] is not dynamic_extent.

7 Returns:

24.7.�.6 Layout specializations of submdspan_offset [mdspan.submdspan.offset]

  template<class Extents, class... SliceSpecifiers>
    constexpr size_t submdspan_offset(
      const layout_left::mapping<Extents>& src, 
      SliceSpecifiers ... slices);

  template<class Extents, class... SliceSpecifiers>
    constexpr size_t submdspan_mapping(
      const layout_right::mapping<Extents>& src, 
      SliceSpecifiers ... slices);

  template<class Extents, class... SliceSpecifiers>
    constexpr size_t submdspan_mapping(
      const layout_stride::mapping<Extents>& src, 
      SliceSpecifiers ... slices);

1 Let index_type name the type typename Extents::index_type.

2 Constraints:

3 Mandates: For each rank index k of src.extents(), exactly one of the following is true:

4 Preconditions: For each rank index r of src.extents(), all of the following are true:

5 Effects: Let P be a parameter pack such that is_same_v<make_index_sequence<rank()>, index_sequence<P...>> is true. Equivalent to: return map(first_<index_type>(P, slices...)...);

24.7.�.7 submdspan function [mdspan.submdspan.submdspan]

// [mdspan.submdspan], submdspan creation
template<class ElementType, class Extents, class LayoutPolicy,
         class AccessorPolicy, class... SliceSpecifiers>
  constexpr auto submdspan(
    const mdspan<ElementType, Extents, LayoutPolicy, AccessorPolicy>& src,
    SliceSpecifiers...slices) -> see below;

1 Let index_type name the type typename Extents::index_type.

2 Constraints:

3 Mandates:

4 Preconditions: Let sub_map be the result of submdspan_mapping(src.mapping(), slices...). Then:

5 Effects: Equivalent to

  size_t offset = submdspan_offset(src.mapping(), args...);
  auto sub_map = submdspan_mapping(src.mapping(), args...);
  return mdspan(src.accessor().offset(src.data(), offset),
                sub_map,
                AccessorPolicy::offset_policy(src.accessor()));

[Example:

Given a rank-3 mdspan grid3d representing a three-dimensional grid of regularly spaced points in a rectangular prism, the function zero_surface sets all elements on the surface of the 3-dimensional shape to zero. It does so by reusing a function zero_2d that takes a rank-2 mdspan.

// zero out all elements in an mdspan
template<class T, class E, class L, class A>
void zero_2d(mdspan<T,E,L,A> a) {
  static_assert(a.rank() == 2);
  for(int i=0; i<a.extent(0); i++)
    for(int j=0; j<a.extent(1); j++)
      a[i,j] = 0;
}

// zero out just the surface
template<class T, class E, class L, class A>
void zero_surface(mdspan<T,E,L,A> grid3d) {
  static_assert(grid3d.rank() == 3);
  zero_2d(submdspan(a, 0, full_extent, full_extent));
  zero_2d(submdspan(a, full_extent, 0, full_extent));
  zero_2d(submdspan(a, full_extent, full_extent, 0));
  zero_2d(submdspan(a, a.extent(0)-1, full_extent, full_extent));
  zero_2d(submdspan(a, full_extent, a.extent(1)-1, full_extent));
  zero_2d(submdspan(a, full_extent, full_extent, a.extent(2)-1));
}

- end example]