From JANSHEP@torolab2.vnet.ibm.com Wed Sep 21 14:59:00 1994 Received: from vnet.ibm.com by dkuug.dk with SMTP id AA22782 (5.65c8/IDA-1.4.4j for ); Thu, 22 Sep 1994 01:02:02 +0200 Message-Id: <199409212302.AA22782@dkuug.dk> Received: from TOROLAB2 by VNET.IBM.COM (IBM VM SMTP V2R2) with BSMTP id 4065; Wed, 21 Sep 94 19:01:44 EDT Date: Wed, 21 Sep 94 18:59:00 EDT From: "Janice Shepherd" To: sc22wg5@dkuug.dk Subject: x3j3 letter ballot X-Charset: ASCII X-Char-Esc: 29 While this is an X3J3 letter ballot, comments from non-X3J3 members are also welcome. To X3J3 - This is the 006 post meeting 130 ballot. This ballot is being conducted by email. No hardcopy will be mailed. Please respond by email. If you are unable to respond by email please contact me. Please let me know if you have any concerns about the ballot. The ballot will end at midnight Oct 22nd (that is, it includes all day of the 22nd) If you want to make a comment about an interpretation (you must make a comment if you are voting No) please try to put the comment in the following format: number vote lastname Comment text .... more comment .... eg. 0 Y Shepherd I really like these edits! This format makes it easier for me to sort the comments by interpretation number. You do not have to use the ballot form listed below to indicate your vote. Sending me a note indicating "I vote yes without comments on all items except for the following ..." is an acceptable form of voting. Other forms of voting are fine too, as long as I can understand your vote. David Mattoon: Please issue the paper below a number for the November meeting and include it in the premeeting distribution. Thanks. Janice C. Shepherd. (416)-448-3101 To reply by email mail to janshep@torolab2.vnet.ibm.com ========= letter ballot X3J3 94-006 ....cut-off date Oct. 22 1994 ======== To: X3J3 From: Janice C. Shepherd Subject: 94-006 Letter Ballot (post meeting 130) Date: Sept 22 1994 X3J3 approval of Fortran 90 defect management items in document X3J3/94-006 as updated at the end of meeting 130. There are 21 items in 94-006 that have the status "X3J3 draft response". These 21 items are listed below, together with boxes to indicate your approval (Yes or Yes-with-comments) or disapproval (No) of each item. Any disapproved items must be accompanied by reasons, either in the space provided or in text at the end of the ballot. [email note - in the list below, "Y" indicates the "Yes" column (without comments), "wc" next to "Y" represents the "Yes-with- comments" column, and "N" indicates the "No" column] The cut-off date for the letter ballot is end of the day on Oct. 22 '94. The content of the 21 items has been sent in an earlier email note. This new content is not yet available on the ftp server. If you did not receive the 21 items then please send a note to janshep@torolab2.vnet.ibm.com Y|wc N 93-006 Item |_|_| |_| 000027 Requirements for pointers and target association |_|_| |_| 000030 Length of character literals in array constructors |_|_| |_| 000041 Procedure with target dummy argument requires explicit interface |_|_| |_| 000049 Characteristics of function results |_|_| |_| 000081 Pointer actual argument overlap |_|_| |_| 000083 Extending generic intrinsic procedures |_|_| |_| 000086 USE and host association |_|_| |_| 000100 ASSOCIATED intrinsic and zero-sized objects |_|_| |_| 000121 ";" As a Statement Separator |_|_| |_| 000129 Array constructors in initialization expressions |_|_| |_| 000135 INTENT(IN) conformance |_|_| |_| 000137 array-element in data-implied-do |_|_| |_| 000139 INTRINSIC, EXTERNAL attribute questions |_|_| |_| 000143 Use association and functions/subroutines/intrinsics |_|_| |_| 000147 Generic name resolution |_|_| |_| 000177 Structures in EQUIVALENCE lists |_|_| |_| 000179 DO variable with POINTER attribute |_|_| |_| 000180 Unambiguous generic references |_|_| |_| 000181 in STOP and PAUSE statements |_|_| |_| 000182 Intrinsics in statement functions |_|_| |_| 000183 Unambiguous procedure overloading