From martin@ocfmail.ocf.llnl.gov Thu Apr 21 08:08:53 1994
Received: from ocfmail.ocf.llnl.gov by dkuug.dk with SMTP id AA26701
  (5.65c8/IDA-1.4.4j for <SC22WG5@dkuug.dk>); Fri, 22 Apr 1994 00:08:59 +0200
Received: by ocfmail.ocf.llnl.gov (4.1/SMI-4.0)
	id AA24710; Thu, 21 Apr 94 15:08:53 PDT
Date: Thu, 21 Apr 94 15:08:53 PDT
From: martin@ocfmail.ocf.llnl.gov (Jeanne T Martin)
Message-Id: <9404212208.AA24710@ocfmail.ocf.llnl.gov>
To: SC22WG5@dkuug.dk
Subject: Preliminary Results of Corrigendum 2 Ballot
X-Charset: ASCII
X-Char-Esc: 29


To:      WG5
From:    Jeanne Martin, Convenor
Subject: Preliminary Results of Corrigendum 2 Ballot

I received ballots from the following:

Countries:
  Japan
  UK
  US

Individuals:
  Adams
  Bezirtzoglou
  Bierman
  Cohen
  Dedo
  Ellis
  Gorelik
  Griffiths
  Hirchert
  Levine
  Maine
  Moss
  Muxworthy
  Reid
  Rolison
  Roth
  Schonauer
  Schonfelder
  Shepherd (IBM)
  Snyder
  Terpstra
  Ushkova
  Wagener
  Whitlock (DEC)

If I missed any ballots or you notice any discrepancies in the results below,
please send me a message.

The titles of the 49 items are listed below, "Y" indicates the "Yes" column
(without comments), "wc" next to "Y" represents the "Yes-with-comments"
column, and "N" indicates the "No" column. The results tallied by countries
precede the results tallied by individuals.


  Y|wc  N                          N965 Item

|02|1| |0|
|23|0| |1| 000000b Minor edits and corrections to ISO/IEC 1539:1991 (E)

|02|0| |1|
|15|1| |8| 000004 Blanks in format specifications in free source form

|03|0| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000011 Multiple accessible defined operator and assignment interfaces

|03|0| |0|
|23|1| |0| 000029 Class of a defined operator

|03|0| |0|
|21|2| |1| 000030 Length of character literals in array constructors

|02|1| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000033 Interface blocks with the same name in a program

|03|0| |0|
|23|0| |1| 000039 Association of a pointer actual argument with a dummy argument

|03|0| |0|
|23|0| |1| 000054 Resolving generic procedure references

|02|0| |1|
|18|2| |4| 000058 Ambiguous use of "keyword"

|02|0| |1|
|20|1| |3| 000071 Use association and common block names

|03|0| |0|
|21|3| |0| 000073 Description of the MERGE intrinsic function

|03|0| |0|
|23|1| |0| 000075 Interface blocks in block data

|03|0| |0|
|23|1| |0| 000076 Attributes, properties, characteristics

|03|0| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000077 Miscellaneous questions

|03|0| |0|
|22|2| |0| 000082 Host association and generic names

|03|0| |0|
|23|1| |0| 000087 PARAMETER statements and SAVE statements

|03|0| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000089 Errors in the DATA statement description

|03|0| |0|
|23|0| |1| 000092 Pointer and storage association

|03|0| |0|
|23|1| |0| 000093 Scalar pointer function results

|02|0| |1|
|20|3| |1| 000097 Specification expression

|02|1| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000099 Generic interfaces

|02|0| |1|
|14|2| |8| 000100 ASSOCIATED intrinsic and zero-sized objects

|03|0| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000102 Returned value for INQUIRE POSITION= on an empty file

|03|0| |0|
|22|2| |0| 000105 Parallel evaluation of operands and arguments

|03|0| |0|
|23|0| |1| 000106 Multiple USE of modules; renaming rules

|03|0| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000108 Referencing disassociated pointers

|03|0| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000111 Array constructors in masked assignment statements

|03|0| |0|
|23|0| |1| 000112 Sequence derived type external functions

|03|0| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000113 Ordering of array specification and initialization

|03|0| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000116 Scoping units and statement labels

|03|0| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000117 Use of MODULE PROCEDURE statement in internal procedures

|03|0| |0|
|23|1| |0| 000123 Result of INT(A) not equal to A for non-default integers

|02|1| |0|
|22|2| |0| 000124 Result of LBOUND for assumed-size arrays

|03|0| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000126 Character Entry statements and Partial Association

|01|2| |0|
|20|1| |3| 000127 Is a module a global entity?

|03|0| |0|
|23|1| |0| 000128 Use associated generic names and renaming

|02|1| |0|
|18|3| |3| 000129 Array constructors in initialization expressions

|03|0| |0|
|21|_2 |1| 000130 Multiple statements on line with END statement

|03|0| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000131 Formatted Input and Kind Type Parameters

|03|0| |0|
|22|2| |0| 000132 SYSTEM_CLOCK intrinsic conformance requirements

|03|0| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000133 Definition of RtokenS as used in section 3.3.1

|03|0| |0|
|22|1| |1| 000144 Specification expressions and implicit typing.

|03|0| |0|
|23|0| |1| 000150 Undefinition of implied-DO variables in I/O statements

|02|1| |0|
|18|3| |3| 000151 Defined Operators with POINTER Operands

|03|0| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000152 Processor dependent values for list and namelist directed
                  output

|02|1| |0|
|21|2| |1| 000153 Defined Operations, dummy arguments INTENT(IN)

|02|0| |1|
|21|0| |3| 000155 Multiple USE statements, rename and only lists.

|02|1| |0|
|22|0| |2| 000157 LBOUND and UBOUND return values

|03|0| |0|
|24|0| |0| 000170 Argument Keywords and Intrinsic Procedures

Thus, the following items passed with no negative votes and no comments:

11 77 89 102 108 111 113 116 117 126 131 133 152 170

The following items passed with no negative votes but may need editorial
adjustments:

29 33 73 75 76 82 87 93 99 105 123 124 128 132

The following items will definitely be returned to X3J3:

4 100 129

The status of the remaining 18 items is still under consideration.  Seven of
these contain no edits and (unless changed) would not be reflected in 
Corrigenda 2 in any case. 

The reasons for negative votes and comments, when extracted and sorted by
item, fill 21 pages.  I will not distribute this information electronically,
but it will be made available to the 129th X3J3 meeting and included in a
forthcoming WG5 distribution. 

I suggest that determination of the final content of Corrigenda 2 be delayed
until the WG5 meeting in August.  

Jeanne Martin
email: jtm@llnl.gov          postal code: L-300
phone: (510) 422-3753        fax: (510) 423-8704
Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
Livermore, CA 94550