From JANSHEP@torolab2.vnet.ibm.com Wed Sep 1 11:37:57 1993 Received: from vnet.ibm.com by dkuug.dk with SMTP id AA03649 (5.65c8/IDA-1.4.4j for ); Wed, 1 Sep 1993 21:38:34 +0200 Message-Id: <199309011938.AA03649@dkuug.dk> Received: from TOROLAB2 by vnet.IBM.COM (IBM VM SMTP V2R2) with BSMTP id 2554; Wed, 01 Sep 93 15:37:54 EDT Date: Wed, 1 Sep 93 15:37:57 EDT From: "Janice Shepherd" To: sc22wg5@dkuug.dk Subject: X3J3 Interpretation ballot X-Charset: ASCII X-Char-Esc: 29 Hi, It has been suggested that I send a copy of this letter ballot to the S22WG5 email. My apologies to those who will be receiving duplicate copies. X3J3 is holding a letter ballot on the current set of interpretations that have status "X3J3 draft response.". While only members of X3J3 can have a vote in the letter ballot, comments from non-members on any of the interpretations being balloted are welcome and appreciated. Our goal is to write correct interpretations. Early feed-back from WG5 members will help us achieve that goal. The current draft of 93-006 is available through the ftp server: ftp.ncsa.uiuc.edu: In directory x3j3: 93-006Ar2.0.Z 93-006Ar2.100.Z Thanks. Janice C. Shepherd. IBM Toronto Lab. --------------------------------------------------------------------- To X3J3 - This is the 006 post meeting 126 ballot. This ballot is being conducted by email. No hardcopy will be mailed. Please respond by email. If you are unable to respond by email please contact me. Please let me know if you have any concerns about the ballot. The ballot will end at midnight Sept 20th. I've requested a paper number for the ballot and it will be included in the premeeting distribution for meeting 127. It has been suggested that it would be useful if I could provide to X3J3 a list of any comments on the interpretations sorted by interpretation number. To help me achieve this goal please use the following format for comments: - indicate the interpretation number, whether the comment is with a Yes or No vote and your last name beside the first line of your comment. For example: 0 Y Shepherd The start of a comment ..... more comment...... 5 N Shepherd Text of the comment ..... Thanks. Janice C. Shepherd. (416)-448-3101 To reply by email mail to janshep@torolab2.vnet.ibm.com ========= letter ballot X3J3 93-246.....cut-off date Sept 20, 1993 ========= X3J3 approval of Fortran 90 defect management items in document X3J3/93-006 as updated at the end of meeting 126. There are 33 items in 93-006 that have the status "X3J3 draft response". These 33 items are listed below, together with boxes to indicate your approval (Yes or Yes-with-comments) or disapproval (No) of each item. Any disapproved items must be accompanied by reasons, either in the space provided or in text at the end of the ballot. [email note - in the list below, "Y" indicates the "Yes" column (without comments), "wc" next to "Y" represents the "Yes-with- comments" column, and "N" indicates the "No" column] As the latest version of 93-006 has been distributed, a copy of the interpretations being balloted is not included. The version of the 93-006 that is basis of the ballot was distributed on Aug 6th 1993. The summary section at the top of that 93-006 incorrectly showed the status of interpretations 12 and 114 as X instead of D. The status field in the text of the interpretation is the correct one (namely "X3J3 draft response"). Following this ballot, those items approved, together with those already having the status "X3J3 approved; ready for WG5" in 93-006, will be forwarded to WG5 for further processing as Fortran 90 defect management items. Y|wc N 93-006 Item |_|_| |_| 000001 Equivalence of expression evaluations |_|_| |_| 000012 Type of a named constant when there is implicit mapping |_|_| |_| 000027 Requirements for pointers and target association |_|_| |_| 000028 Precedence of use or host association |_|_| |_| 000076 Attributes, properties, characteristics |_|_| |_| 000077 Misc. questions |_|_| |_| 000081 Pointer actual argument overlap |_|_| |_| 000082 Host association and generic names |_|_| |_| 000083 Generic override of intrinsic procedure |_|_| |_| 000087 PARAMETER statements and SAVE statements |_|_| |_| 000090 Subroutine and function names in nested scopes |_|_| |_| 000096 Definition of "Declaration" |_|_| |_| 000097 Specification expression |_|_| |_| 000098 KIND param and list directed I/O |_|_| |_| 000099 Generic interfaces |_|_| |_| 000100 ASSOCIATED intrinsic and zero-sized objects |_|_| |_| 000101 Specification statements |_|_| |_| 000111 Array constructors in masked assignment statements |_|_| |_| 000114 Named constant attribute specification |_|_| |_| 000122 Intrinsic procedures in modules |_|_| |_| 000124 Result of LBOUND for assumed-size arrays |_|_| |_| 000125 Copy in/copy out of target dummy arguments |_|_| |_| 000126 Character entry statements and partial association |_|_| |_| 000127 Is a module a global entity? |_|_| |_| 000128 Use associated generic names and renaming |_|_| |_| 000131 Formatted Input and Kind Type Parameters |_|_| |_| 000132 SYSTEM_CLOCK intrinsic conformance requirements |_|_| |_| 000133 Definition of "token" as used in section 3.3.1 |_|_| |_| 000134 PARAMETER, NAMELIST, interpretation 114, and implicit typing |_|_| |_| 000135 INTENT(IN) conformance |_|_| |_| 000140 TARGET attribute for a derived-type object with a pointer component |_|_| |_| 000142 Namelist I/O |_|_| |_| 000144 Specification expressions and implicit typing.