From martin@ocfmail.ocf.llnl.gov Wed Mar 17 06:26:24 1993 Received: from ocfmail.ocf.llnl.gov by dkuug.dk with SMTP id AA23845 (5.65c8/IDA-1.4.4j for ); Wed, 17 Mar 1993 23:26:07 +0100 Received: by ocfmail.ocf.llnl.gov (4.1/SMI-4.0) id AA15450; Wed, 17 Mar 93 14:26:24 PST Date: Wed, 17 Mar 93 14:26:24 PST From: martin@ocfmail.ocf.llnl.gov (Jeanne Martin) Message-Id: <9303172226.AA15450@ocfmail.ocf.llnl.gov> To: SC22WG5@dkuug.dk Subject: Corrected Results of Ballot on N865 X-Charset: ASCII X-Char-Esc: 29 [Please consider the results distributed yesterday as preliminary. Here is a more correct summary. -JTM] To: WG5 From: Jeanne Martin, Convenor Subject: Corrected Results of Ballot on N865 Here are the vote counts on the ballot on N865. Since there were many general comments and many editorial comments, I believe we should postpone sending the corrigendum to SC22 until WG5 has approved the actual document. Therefore I will send all the comments to the document editor and ask for a draft document for review and approval at the July WG5 meeting. (The comments will appear in the next WG5 distribution as well.) Votes are recorded [Yes(Yes with comments)-No] followed by (those voting yes with comments) {those voting no} Country Votes Countries voting: China, Germany, Japan, UK, US All items except 13, 57, 84, and 98 [5(0)-0] 13 [2(0)-3] {Germany, Japan, UK} 57 [4(1)-0] (UK) 84 [4(1)-0] (UK) 98 [3(0)-2] {Japan, UK} Items 13 and 98 are considered to have failed the ballot at this time, but this decision may be reconsidered at the WG5 meeting. All other items are considered to have passed, but some may be changed based on the comments. Individual Votes Individuals voting: Adams, Bezirtzoglou, Bierman, Cohen, Ellis, Griffiths, Hirchert, Hoffert, Kelble, Lahey, Leonard [0-67 only], Martin, Mattoon, Munchhausen, Muxworthy, Pollicini, Reid, Rolison, Roth, Schonauer, Schonfelder, Shen, Tait, Terpstra, Wagener, Weaver 0 [24(2)-0] (Pollicini, Shen) 1 [23(1)-2] (Munchhausen) {Rolison, Shen} 2 [24(2)-0] (Munchhausen, Rolison) 3 [25(1)-0] (Rolison) 5 [25(0)-0] [Roth abstained] 6 [24(1)-1] (Rolison) {Schonfelder} 9 [25(1)-0] (Rolison) 10 [25(1)-0] (Rolison) 13 [18(1)-7] (Rolison) {Cohen, Ellis, Muxworthy, Pollicini, Reid, Schonfelder, Shen} 14 [25(1)-0] (Leonard) 15 [23(2)-1] (Rolison, Shen) {Pollicini} 16 [26(0)-0] 17 [23(3)-0] (Kelble, Leonard, Rolison) 18 [26(0)-0] 19 [24(0)-2] {Rolison, Roth} 20 [23(2)-1] (Rolison, Schonfleder) {Leonard} 21 [25(1)-0] (Schonfelder) 22 [25(1)-0] (Schonfelder) 24 [26(0)-0] 25 [25(1)-0] (Rolison) 26 [24(0)-2] {Martin, Tait} 31 [24(1)-1] (Munchhausen) {Schonfelder} 32 [26(0)-0] 36 [24(2)-0] (Griffiths, Rolison) 37 [25(0)-1] {Schonfleder} 38 [23(1)-2] (Reid) {Schonfelder, Shen} 40 [26(0)-0] 42 [25(1)-0] (Muxworthy) 43 [26(0)-0] 44 [25(0)-1] {Rolison} 45 [25(1)-0] (Leonard) 46 [25(0)-1] {Shen} 47 [25(0)-1] {Leonard} 48 [24(1)-1] (Rolison) {Leonard} 50 [23(1)-2] (Leonard) {Pollicini, Roth} 51 [24(2)-0] (Kelble, Rolison) 52 [24(2)-0] (Kelble, Rolison) 53 [26(0)-0] 55 [25(0)-1] {Rolison} 56 [24(0)-2] {Leonard, Rolison} 57 [23(2)-1] (Muxworthy, Rolison) {Schonfelder} 59 [24(2)-0] (Rolison, Schonfelder} 60 [25(1)-0] (Rolison) 61 [25(1)-0] (Rolison) 62 [25(1)-0] (Pollicini) 63 [25(1)-0] (Rolison) 64 [26(0)-0] 65 [25(1)-0] (Pollicini) 66 [26(0)-0] 67 [26(0)-0] [After this point the total number voting was 25] 68 [24(1)-0] (Reid) 69 [23(2)-0] (Rolison, Tait) 72 [23(1)-1] (Rolison) {Tait} 74 [24(1)-0] (Kelble) 78 [23(0)-2] {Schonfelder, Shen} 80 [24(1)-0] (Reid) 84 [24(1)-0] (Reid) 85 [25(0)-0] 94 [24(1)-0] (Pollicini) 95 [24(1)-0] (Pollicini) 98 [22(0)-3] {Cohen, Muxworthy, Reid} 103 [21(3)-1] (Kelble, Pollicini, Reid) {Tait} 104 [24(0)-1] {Tait} 107 [25(0)-0] 109 [23(1)-1] (Kelble) {Tait} 110 [24(1)-0] (Rolison) 115 [24(1)-0] (Rolison) 118 [23(0)-2] {Tait, Pollicini} 119 [24(1)-0] (Rolison) 120 [25(0)-0]