From owner-sc22wg5+sc22wg5-dom9=www.open-std.org@open-std.org Sat Oct 24 00:11:32 2020 Return-Path: X-Original-To: sc22wg5-dom9 Delivered-To: sc22wg5-dom9@www.open-std.org Received: by www.open-std.org (Postfix, from userid 521) id 032EC358A95; Sat, 24 Oct 2020 00:11:32 +0200 (CEST) Delivered-To: sc22wg5@open-std.org Received: from sonic303-6.consmr.mail.bf2.yahoo.com (sonic303-6.consmr.mail.bf2.yahoo.com [74.6.131.45]) (using TLSv1 with cipher AES128-SHA (128/128 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by www.open-std.org (Postfix) with ESMTP id 6427A358771 for ; Sat, 24 Oct 2020 00:11:25 +0200 (CEST) DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=att.net; s=s1024; t=1603491083; bh=45Va15GZjwOB6KZYXsk5MgtM2cNPiP8mPFBgO/xccgc=; h=Date:From:To:Subject:References:From:Subject; b=SkSg1z0/hrkd6uJKpRWyUg9P02a8h6rKtdi3HHUsq4C221IJdppw6ID2gl8JcYSu4qbVVWEjVWs8i5RJoiHx/2u+pwjqwN1rAjRv5bSOkXqJXNLGR3mdvMREoI4XtMeYuXzySjYSI50jQHiy/MUoaoj/kglz7ZC5NHEUdAEsOlM= X-SONIC-DKIM-SIGN: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=yahoo.com; s=s2048; t=1603491083; bh=CZixpCNLWHykCoPanUUrDNA0ykm6k0mvzD04mxKdvG9=; h=Date:From:To:Subject; b=QKfxdKwHlcka2Eht4MLUVgbadC7rm2MoYhHA7IOvxMGo3+0fTheDa/wwIeP2LgWXC6NBy1tOVGTMa9vP2jDHYRz8Fh6IBMZl6Ohn8xc+zJ3tT4qNytEUEUcmgSz3T8AKbUttwzXgf31JBVD8UD/tekzpIFdvIfbabPMpQWefMCabK70JfSW2Wi/5yTj9lU7Giw8Sh1cSfPg30IclbI/BqenWKQUKwkJJe8UjXH/DfjhAm4hB0D86Nvc5eSdRacJMdY9eieh6CDUjVE4vxkvHrjqwV4zl3EkTnUAZrB07vy0w+Gbd/vob4m0sFhWFExZbKEOIrelfeQz1870qg55T6g== X-YMail-OSG: rG.keCkVM1mF9qeFk2MN.Vxia9lr8rxjqCFHilHZLOVf7xXDY6feqZi4lRiT9rf ufXLS5oO6NFQCsDpYRNR7vi6uAJA2Gdh6Fgl.od1DIU0ShSywK05lqS4ybR5GFVFejZsj2xZ8f9k HZD_Z53I_vKJzcS7NqX7VCXXv65_B0Zv4yU1NKzYKIzV5C_21JJskcce3m1NIDG_y2QEHRkodLFZ p06GwlbG3GJV29TbED54Q0f5w1GeHomcHgr.zAo.WxDSxcai0QkHxkjOg5fALJXFTrvyFDASlClH EcE37VMC3DIMFKPDtG6.U5uBbhOnSV0mNsZ.IYCWSeFaJkHS_mNuALk6I21Bht7kjgEX7Fb7TQG1 aXhvoLQ3IpUbdpQzF5skmYDWfioEkA79vmK4dbnn3qrio5iVYC6ZYX9Zj5yy2JO7iCV96o5yLbVG zOIctS0pxenIYFBYFBbt0hsWS9Q2ov.S3BhEUTTht5HweYgB2_LFEe3gd7SJdbJkKWFDYwIinNWo JqMCqbCM2q7tlyt0x6rF0mytcGJzGBeAyQES7xfbUiYXGUuNOfPR1zrV01mxIwSmXT.e34Mlkd2W wF0Mm9ie7itEhsWFKPw_H2EyV8Y_hvU0BI6ULG2Zp5wpoS5XLtrCw56jcaYrpeeNko7_mm9OFFBn kCKi1Bfq9MocatnYVqTxrwZ4xU1PR5lFgzXXc_I_hTBTxtPgVEGdMZ3EgfvspWzuo0d08NrgGj1Z ejqAMEPJf_HdgtmS15Cyp3EEyF2PpRoQwzP8kuiL95fusDvakMAOanWqKdjrPRKVEMSrcw2w9kpf BJrpJJlNB5IpfxW94rL3YduQ0y7SV1VMLt0laPkxuq71xUHtYSWxMB9RzvFEmiEtvFMfAOAKHY0I q1dh2lrgeRleFfcHfNdJs6WZULiX6HTV0xDIIuez4NPnJCV69.xrGMtIfssJYk0h4NuOdkWnkLBA aJtedT2STFacL0GAw6_F62C._5TLa0xXrlM8vKfZ8YfE20xWWsm6RPG2ANaNjvzt4qqSmAAePpef d94KPHcikOfJv517qllDbBrADfFHfvMLYR7HE5vJ67NnuUZnEl1_Ls0v5gbLUnNEA90py4Gn.oqN RMiBer5gchzjIqR.YrgLjn6CpfgZXn2W8OpvEkUZQJdsnWfZUk3kU57OjNq2EV9n2GLRo3ybsOc7 0mpfRKm_kVXIlURvyKxTi_Qi9KeckLvnlB19vq5KlgnPjWC8voKyVdnm.qDJJHVOn9o5KXdIQzBR q3_OReIn3dr967VVfJOSKwGXy96PlDB6XqYlMZvZ7Ktx04kRqN0KeycPyo19uzLY8gLb4KfLeG4h vXqXRuZ6lgkiVsIKdGDT.xmY4N3hpX7VkiLJUbQUDr5ACc4XFa_wkXsQqnP2s4r26FDdGdpwQMon MDVu5Ud_r2hHBQv.kgF12SbbQ7oJ7PVAHHARY8pOUlTKoHn.Tp_jK9QrHm.MK0bp5Y.e9aA01p5Y xV5FDG9OFsCH9t_9UwvLYY09yOBp5KSrQVfXsaimyVM24K5yD362KimcS8jTIuvHNCrzZzi3o9ov R9I01VhLFRcLqBNtGlHglax1bLbK7ZIr6Taygu4SRZhzPPdcu.C7rmVH6OiS6yscp7IUY_zB6bWg xds7SBo570_xxq75BLZ6_S1TvcBQGUyhpuhzaSnl6vhObathOKCxxvrTGpndwFewNA6caYjiwizo hzrH0TMIAKk4v9DpStIPQNh6i_xjd2mQYzqwq87Sukvf6tJo4fnXry90sfdiE04ggyPE4B.47W9y gLi6ZkFf7fVX_jreAmVa3BF5bwe2oTeDbeV83BCnupuJJY7QZVniReNB1TBTyBywLCBzplSjac7d c3Q2UvfYrI.nISEAOyYwN8yykdvFGcWW_h.uzp2M_5vEc_.E0Bj71HFyt2I8bZOWbjCRBgM7vPqG ACxhu_ArzWNzQxHckFySrcb0DVk1kJog_ZQEiUI41qvM2nP1h_8H5G_AVdONGnDiwWMQKjmEiQHy LAF4t.ffo1xrVCIVcirSSEY2GtxGlNeRXh3JMeBgZ7BpG1YuDOW4hOLubab7pQFzqeAhNBigqffK fmcTyAONejejZDsYoU2qL1a91Cupu882uewVJPRUGL_Q8XUoUa.SP0AzwfGY8.hY7u_x1fD7bHSj a8ob7T14Jc.2mlgHFlCroQpql_qADQum9xZnS52_3y9V7peTFuroq8RpOVn9hxAWrA._1iKvQ4tr ArNXc7rf0NUZ1zaKXe7yg4QuTRJfKs2FwUfGitTWnrJT1bOZcoSxC_XNQr.BpX2h2LIUwP_pHcEE ZXi_VWzpGWM4flI9hBdsWmPpgr7hkIRlsPHBl4jxHQCMdxNtemM51WqQEbYbmBrDLKaYPdBSqZJk gHLXp.9L.80Rgnd3c.BZfH8sXhL9pH7l4Khail6IaAJYcJjI9eYZ5u4NEE06sXRwQVsfs23B4D50 613R7RRU02aWmljfViaiMgSrfW7mco2LL3m3BZTWK Received: from sonic.gate.mail.ne1.yahoo.com by sonic303.consmr.mail.bf2.yahoo.com with HTTP; Fri, 23 Oct 2020 22:11:23 +0000 Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2020 22:11:22 +0000 (UTC) From: Robert Corbett To: "sc22wg5@open-std.org" Message-ID: <880209950.2271739.1603491082051@mail.yahoo.com> Subject: Fortran 2018 ballot #1 MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="----=_Part_2271738_1191852920.1603491082050" References: <880209950.2271739.1603491082051.ref@mail.yahoo.com> X-Mailer: WebService/1.1.16868 YMailNorrin Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; Win64; x64; rv:81.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/81.0 Sender: owner-sc22wg5@open-std.org Precedence: bulk ------=_Part_2271738_1191852920.1603491082050 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable The following Fortran 2018 interpretations are being balloted: Yes=C2=A0 No Number=C2=A0=C2=A0 Title -Y- --- F18/001=C2=A0 ACOSH principal value specification is wrong -Y- --- F18/002=C2=A0 Internal procedures in generic interface blocks -Y- --- F18/003=C2=A0 Pointer association of component of non-definable sel= ector -Y- --- F18/004=C2=A0 Program execution sequence with failed images -Y- --- F18/005=C2=A0 Does INPUT_UNIT really identify the same unit as *? -Y- --- F18/006=C2=A0 Connection of INPUT_UNIT on different images -Y- --- F18/008=C2=A0 Contradictory assumed-rank requirements -Y- --- F18/009=C2=A0 Bad examples in IEEE_ARITHMETIC functions -Y- --- F18/010=C2=A0 Categories of pure procedures -Y- --- F18/011=C2=A0 Categories of elemental procedures -Y- --- F18/012=C2=A0 Internal procedure in a generic interface -Y- --- F18/013=C2=A0 TEAM_NUMBER arguments and intrinsic function are ambi= guous -Y- --- F18/014=C2=A0 Type of OPERATION arguments to the REDUCE intrinsic --- -N- F18/015=C2=A0 Example in C.6.8 is wrong -Y- --- F18/016=C2=A0 Host association changes in Fortran 2018 -Y- --- F18/017=C2=A0 Final subroutine invocation order -Y- --- F18/018=C2=A0 Public namelist and private variable --------------------------------------------------------------------------- F18/015 N The proposed replacement example is pointlessly complicated. ------=_Part_2271738_1191852920.1603491082050 Content-Type: text/html; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
The following Fortran 2018 interpr= etations are being balloted:

Yes  No Number   Title-Y- --- F18/001  ACOSH principal value specification is wrong
-Y-= --- F18/002  Internal procedures in generic interface blocks
-Y- -= -- F18/003  Pointer association of component of non-definable selector=
-Y- --- F18/004  Program execution sequence with failed images
= -Y- --- F18/005  Does INPUT_UNIT really identify the same unit as *?-Y- --- F18/006  Connection of INPUT_UNIT on different images
-Y-= --- F18/008  Contradictory assumed-rank requirements
-Y- --- F18/0= 09  Bad examples in IEEE_ARITHMETIC functions
-Y- --- F18/010 = Categories of pure procedures
-Y- --- F18/011  Categories of eleme= ntal procedures
-Y- --- F18/012  Internal procedure in a generic in= terface
-Y- --- F18/013  TEAM_NUMBER arguments and intrinsic functi= on are ambiguous
-Y- --- F18/014  Type of OPERATION arguments to th= e REDUCE intrinsic
--- -N- F18/015  Example in C.6.8 is wrong
-Y= - --- F18/016  Host association changes in Fortran 2018
-Y- --- F18= /017  Final subroutine invocation order
-Y- --- F18/018  Publi= c namelist and private variable

------------------------------------= ---------------------------------------
F18/015 N

The proposed re= placement example is pointlessly complicated.
------=_Part_2271738_1191852920.1603491082050--